An official website of the United States government
A .mil website belongs to an official U.S. Department of Defense organization in the United States.
A lock (lock ) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .mil website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Home : News : Article View
NEWS | June 22, 2012

Study presented at suicide prevention conference offers glimpse into suicide motives

By Karen Parrish American Forces Press Service

WASHINGTON, - Why? What makes people attempt suicide? It's a vital question, as the answer could help mental health professionals and even friends and family better recognize when they need to step in to help to save a life.

Theories about suicide motives abound, but as one presenter noted June 20 at the annual suicide prevention conference sponsored jointly by the Defense and Veterans Affairs departments, not much data exists on the question.

Craig J. Bryan, a doctor of psychology, is associate director of the National Center for Veterans Studies at the University of Utah and an assistant professor for the university's psychology department. At the conference, he presented the results of a study aimed at identifying the motives of 72 active-duty service members who attempted suicide.

"They had collectively attempted suicide 136 times over their lives," he said, adding that 21 percent never attempted suicide and two participants had made five attempts each.

Study participants - 66 men and six women - ranged in age from 19 to 44 and had served between one and 19 years in the military. Each person referred to the study had been discharged from an inpatient hospital stay for suicide risk.

Bryan noted the study also served as a course of treatment. Phase 1 focused on crisis management and distress tolerance. Phase 2 aimed at problem solving and restructuring of the participants' suicide belief systems, and Phase 3 was dedicated to relapse prevention.

Each participant built a crisis response plan and underwent sleep therapy as part of the study, he said, and patients completed an average of 12 sessions - as many as 17 for some - before "graduating" from the study.

Phase 1 must target emotion regulation, Bryan emphasized. Patients have to learn to deal effectively with painful emotions or they can't progress further in therapy, he said.

Most theories about suicide motivation assume suicidal attempts primarily stem from emotional distress, Bryan said. He described two models of approach and treatment for suicidal behaviors: the "syndromal model," which assumes an underlying psychiatric disorder in suicidal patients, and the "functional model," which seeks to explain why people attempt suicide so patients can learn how to cope with challenges.

Bryan told the conference audience that the "functional model of self-harm" widely referenced in suicide prevention work notes four major groups of possible suicide motives:

- Emotional relief, or the desire to stop bad feelings;

- Feeling generation, or the desire to feel something even if it's bad;

- Avoidance and escape, or the desire to avoid punishment from others or avoid doing something undesirable; and

- Interpersonal influence, or the desire to get attention or "let others know how I feel."

Identifying the "why" is one of the essential ingredients to reduce suicide attempt rates, he said, because once patients understand their motivations, they can develop strategies and coping skills to deal with those challenges.

Bryan said one aim of the study, which used the functional model, was to teach patients "how to suffer in a way that doesn't require you to die."

The study asked participants to identify their own motives for a suicide attempt from a list of 33 potential reasons, which were divided among the functional model's four groups. Each patient chose one to 29 reasons, Bryan said, with 10.43 factors as the mean result.

All participants selected emotional relief, specifically "to stop bad feelings," as a factor, he said, though 95 percent also noted other reasons.

Bryan described the frequency of other factors noted in the study. Participants identified avoidance or escape - with the top single reason being "to get away or escape from other people" - as a factor 82.4 percent of the time. Interpersonal influence was noted by 80.1 percent of participants, with the most-cited response being "to communicate or let others know how desperate you were." And 72.8 percent endorsed feeling generation as a factor, with "to feel something, even if it was pain" as the most common response.

After patients confronted the reasons they had attempted or considered suicide, Bryan said, "It was like a light bulb went on." While all of the participants originally said they attempted suicide because they wanted to die, 95 percent acknowledged after selecting factors they realized they had not wanted to die, but wanted to end emotional pain.

"What this means from a clinical standpoint is we have to start integrating these behavioral [and] functional understandings of suicide attempts into our treatment," he said. "This is a primary mechanism or ingredient of ... behavioral therapy, which is the treatment that we're currently testing for active-duty Soldiers."

As part of the study, participants received a "smart book" during their first 30 minutes of therapy, Bryan said. Patients wrote in the books throughout their course of therapy, adding lessons learned during each session about what was working for them.

At the end of Phase 3, the smart book comes out again and participants review the lessons and skills, Bryan said. If patients get "stuck" in thinking about how a previous suicide attempt could have been handled differently or how to face a current challenge, the smart books remind them of approaches they learned in therapy. "It is a core intervention," he said.

 

 

Related Articles
U.S. Soldiers with the Army National Guard speak with D.C. locals while patrolling Metro Center Aug 26, 2025. About 2,000 National Guard members are supporting the D.C. Safe and Beautiful mission providing critical support to the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department in ensuring the safety of all who live, work, and visit the District.
Guard Members From Six States, D.C. on Duty in Washington in Support of Local, Fed Authorities
By Sgt. 1st Class Jon Soucy, | Aug. 29, 2025
WASHINGTON – More than 2,000 National Guard Soldiers and Airmen from six states and the District of Columbia are on duty in Washington as part of Joint Task Force – District of Columbia in support of local and federal...

Lt. Gen. H. Steven Blum, chief of the National Guard Bureau, Maj. Gen. Russel Honore, Task Force Katrina commander, and Brig. Gen. John Basilica, 256th Infantry Brigade Combat Team commander, talk to news media during the aftermath of Hurricane Rita on Sep. 29, 2005. Basilica was appointed commander of Task Force Pelican, responsible for coordinating National Guard hurricane response efforts across the State. The task force included tens of thousands of National Guard Soldiers from Louisiana and other states.
Louisiana Guard’s Tiger Brigade Marks 20th Anniversary of Redeployment and Hurricane Response
By Rhett Breerwood, | Aug. 29, 2025
NEW ORLEANS – This fall, the Louisiana National Guard’s 256th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, known as the Tiger Brigade, commemorates the 20th anniversary of its redeployment from Iraq in September 2005, coinciding with the...

Alaska Air National Guard HH-60G Pave Hawk aviators and Guardian Angels, assigned to the 210th and 212th Rescue Squadrons, respectively, conduct a hoist rescue demonstration while participating in a multi-agency hoist symposium at Bryant Army Airfield on Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, Alaska, July 22, 2025. The symposium, hosted by Alaska Army National Guard aviators assigned to Golf Company, 2-211th General Support Aviation Battalion, included U.S. Coast Guard crews assigned to Sector Western Alaska and U.S. Arctic out of Air Stations Kodiak and Sitka, Alaska Air National Guardsmen with the 176th Wing rescue squadrons, U.S. Army aviators from Fort Wainwright’s 1-52nd General Support Aviation Battalion, Alaska State Troopers, and civilian search and rescue professional volunteers from the Alaska Mountain Rescue Group. The collaborative training drew on the participants’ varied backgrounds, experiences, and practices, to enhance hoist proficiency and collective readiness when conducting life-saving search and rescue missions in Alaska’s vast and austere terrain. (Alaska Army National Guard photo by Alejandro Peña)
Alaska Air Guard Conducts Multiple Hoist Rescues of Stranded Rafters on Kichatna River
By Staff Sgt. Seth LaCount, | Aug. 29, 2025
JOINT BASE ELMENDORF-RICHARDSON, Alaska — Alaska Air National Guard members with the 176th Wing rescued three rafters Aug. 28 after their raft flipped over on the Kichatna River.The Alaska Rescue Coordination Center opened...