An official website of the United States government
A .mil website belongs to an official U.S. Department of Defense organization in the United States.
A lock (lock ) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .mil website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Home : News : Article View
NEWS | May 1, 2013

Army secretary favors 'third-party approach' to engage Congress

By David Vergun Army News Service

WASHINGTON - Army leaders may not make the best advocates when it comes to convincing Congress and the American people which systems soldiers really need, Army Secretary John M. McHugh said here yesterday.

On the flip side, Congress is not without its own biases when it comes to those decisions, McHugh told reporters at a Defense Writers Group breakfast.

The path forward, he pointed out, is to use findings from third-party "analytics" sources.

Since third-party sources "don't have skin in the game, they can look at systems in a more detached way, maybe more so than the Army or Congress can," McHugh added.

McHugh, who served in Congress for 17 years, prefaced his remarks by saying he has the utmost respect for congressional oversight.

Nonbiased findings, he said, are particularly necessary as decisions are now being made on which programs to cut, delay, not start or reduce as the effects of sequestration and continuing resolutions continue to take their toll on Army modernization and readiness.

To illustrate the point, he provided two examples where the Army used third-party findings to make its case. The first example was the M1A2 Abrams main battle tank’s System Enhanced Program.

"There's a gap between the numbers we think are accurate and those the manufacturer and others believe are more accurate," he said, referring to the cost of shutting down production.

"We asked [the RAND Corp.] to take a careful look at the cost of taking down the Abrams line and then later starting it back up," McHugh said, implying it would be restarted once funding becomes available and enhancements are ready. The RAND Corp. is a nonprofit organization that helps improve policy and decision making through research and analysis.

RAND analysts said to shut the line down at the Lima, Ohio, plant and reopen it later would cost $342 million.

"That was substantially below the manufacturer's estimate," McHugh said, adding that "we accept that figure as a workable number."

McHugh continued: "It may not be the ideal decision for everyone, but these times suggest we have to prioritize our resources in [the] most appropriate way. It's a great program, but at this time we don't need it, and the money could be spent in other ways."

The Army secretary also cited as an example the Ground Combat Vehicle, or GCV, a replacement for aging armored fighting vehicles. The Army hired the A.T. Kearney industrial and analytics firm to study its production and procurement, McHugh said, and the Army likely will get the firm’s findings by June.

McHugh said he thinks the Army needs GCVs to provide critical capabilities for soldiers on the battlefield, and that he believes the study will support that.

Noting that tens of thousands of soldiers are in Afghanistan, McHugh said discussions on modernization are germane to current operations, not just to a theoretical future war.

Besides approving the Army's budget request and eliminating sequestration, McHugh said, another way Congress could help the Army would be to authorize it to do a specific analysis on a future round of base realignment and closure, known as BRAC.

"We're over-structured," he said, adding that the Army could use another round of BRAC. Having been involved in three rounds of BRAC while serving in Congress, McHugh added, he knows it’s tough.

"They're not fun. I recognize the difficulties [base closings] bring to people's lives," he said. However, he added, money saved through a thoughtful BRAC process could be better spent on keeping safe the soldiers who are in harm's way or on supporting programs such as the Ready and Resilient Campaign.

McHugh said it's a waste to maintain infrastructure "that is simply not useable or isn't being used, and that just adds to our energy inefficiency."

The last BRAC study was done a decade ago and it pointed to 20 percent excess infrastructure, McHugh said.

Meanwhile, McHugh said, the Army has been steadily engaged in the Pacific region for some time now, through humanitarian and natural disaster assistance, training with other armies, strengthening alliances, and building partner capacity.

Despite the fiscal situation, the Army will not cut funding for those engagements, McHugh said, citing some 24 bilateral and multilateral exercises scheduled in the coming year. Also, he said, the National Guard plans to expand its State Partnership Program to nations in that area and elsewhere.

In addition, the Army intends to make the commander of U.S. Army Pacific a four-star general position to put the commander "on a more equal footing to engage with other leaders across the Pacific Rim," McHugh said.

The secretary also said it would be a "mistake" to think of the strategic shift in focus to the Asia-Pacific region as somehow intending to confront China.

"I was very encouraged by the Chinese military leadership's recent visit where [Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Army Gen. Martin E. Dempsey] met with his Chinese counterpart to discuss working cooperatively for mutual interest in the Pacific region," McHugh said. "We want to build and strengthen positive military ties with the Chinese throughout that region. We intend to pursue those efforts on every level."

 

 

Related Articles
U.S. Soldiers with the Army National Guard speak with D.C. locals while patrolling Metro Center Aug 26, 2025. About 2,000 National Guard members are supporting the D.C. Safe and Beautiful mission providing critical support to the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department in ensuring the safety of all who live, work, and visit the District.
Guard Members From Six States, D.C. on Duty in Washington in Support of Local, Fed Authorities
By Sgt. 1st Class Jon Soucy, | Aug. 29, 2025
WASHINGTON – More than 2,000 National Guard Soldiers and Airmen from six states and the District of Columbia are on duty in Washington as part of Joint Task Force – District of Columbia in support of local and federal...

Lt. Gen. H. Steven Blum, chief of the National Guard Bureau, Maj. Gen. Russel Honore, Task Force Katrina commander, and Brig. Gen. John Basilica, 256th Infantry Brigade Combat Team commander, talk to news media during the aftermath of Hurricane Rita on Sep. 29, 2005. Basilica was appointed commander of Task Force Pelican, responsible for coordinating National Guard hurricane response efforts across the State. The task force included tens of thousands of National Guard Soldiers from Louisiana and other states.
Louisiana Guard’s Tiger Brigade Marks 20th Anniversary of Redeployment and Hurricane Response
By Rhett Breerwood, | Aug. 29, 2025
NEW ORLEANS – This fall, the Louisiana National Guard’s 256th Infantry Brigade Combat Team, known as the Tiger Brigade, commemorates the 20th anniversary of its redeployment from Iraq in September 2005, coinciding with the...

Alaska Air National Guard HH-60G Pave Hawk aviators and Guardian Angels, assigned to the 210th and 212th Rescue Squadrons, respectively, conduct a hoist rescue demonstration while participating in a multi-agency hoist symposium at Bryant Army Airfield on Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, Alaska, July 22, 2025. The symposium, hosted by Alaska Army National Guard aviators assigned to Golf Company, 2-211th General Support Aviation Battalion, included U.S. Coast Guard crews assigned to Sector Western Alaska and U.S. Arctic out of Air Stations Kodiak and Sitka, Alaska Air National Guardsmen with the 176th Wing rescue squadrons, U.S. Army aviators from Fort Wainwright’s 1-52nd General Support Aviation Battalion, Alaska State Troopers, and civilian search and rescue professional volunteers from the Alaska Mountain Rescue Group. The collaborative training drew on the participants’ varied backgrounds, experiences, and practices, to enhance hoist proficiency and collective readiness when conducting life-saving search and rescue missions in Alaska’s vast and austere terrain. (Alaska Army National Guard photo by Alejandro Peña)
Alaska Air Guard Conducts Multiple Hoist Rescues of Stranded Rafters on Kichatna River
By Staff Sgt. Seth LaCount, | Aug. 29, 2025
JOINT BASE ELMENDORF-RICHARDSON, Alaska — Alaska Air National Guard members with the 176th Wing rescued three rafters Aug. 28 after their raft flipped over on the Kichatna River.The Alaska Rescue Coordination Center opened...